SMS Pro Aviation Safety Software Blog 4 Airlines & Airports

Difference Between Proactive and Mitigative Risk Controls in Aviation SMS

Posted by Tyler Britton on Apr 25, 2019 6:03:00 AM

What Is a Risk Control in Aviation SMS?

Do you need proactive risk controls in your aviation SMS program?

Hazard identification and risk management are two major activities of formal, aviation safety management systems (SMS). Once the hazard is identified, the safety concern is reported to management for treatment via the SMS' risk management processes. SMS risk management processes evaluate:

  • Affected system(s);
  • Anticipated organizational risk from a risk analysis;
  • Risk assessment to determine priority of the safety concern; and
  • Risk controls.

Simply put, a risk control is measure that an organization takes to either detect manifesting hazards, avoid risks or lessen consequences resulting from an uncontrolled hazard.

Related Articles on Risk Controls in Aviation SMS

A “measure” is simply anything management does with the goals of lessening/avoiding risk and consequences, such as:

  • SMS training courses;
  • Safety policy, procedures, and checklists;
  • Equipment;
  • Risk management tools;
  • Checklist protocols;
  • Daily operational duties/actions; and
  • Physical objects (such as navigation signs, diagrams, etc.).

SMS Pro Fulfills SRM & SA Compliance Requirement

Risk Controls are SMS Focal Point in Risk Management

Risk controls are the ultimate expression of risk management in aviation SMS implementations. Corrective actions and preventative actions, issue management, and safety data are all used with the end goal of implementing risk controls that:

  • Are relevant to a specific safety need;
  • Improve operational safety; and
  • Can be monitored and updated.

As an aviation SMS becomes more mature, the organization will gradually improve the effectiveness and sophistication of risk controls. Employees and stakeholders in robust safety cultures continuously monitor the "systems" for anomalies and promptly submit safety reports as potential safety concerns are identified. Safety management teams react to the reported safety issues. One of subsequent risk management activities is to review the affected systems and evaluate the effectiveness of implemented risk controls, which are also called "control measures" by many safety professionals.

Risk controls need to be monitored and periodically updated to meet changing safety needs and emerging risks. As we have seen, failing risk controls can be reported by stakeholders as they interact with the "system." Other environmental changes requiring action are identified by quality assurance departments through auditing, evaluations and inspections. Through a process of continuous monitoring and improving risk controls, the aviation service provider becomes more efficient and safe.

When we talk about risk controls, we are generally talking about proactive risk controls and mitigative risk controls.

Related Articles on Risk Controls in Aviation SMS

What Is a Proactive Risk Control

Proactive risk controls in aviation SMS programs

Proactive risk controls in aviation SMS implementations are used to avoid risks and prevent undesirable events from happening. Some common examples of proactive risk controls are:

  • Hazard and risk fluency assessments;
  • Hazard identification training;
  • Security equipment;
  • Bird scattering activities;
  • Checklists and procedures;
  • Daily inspections;
  • Signs, lights, navigational objects;
  • Aviation safety meetings; and
  • Hazard reporting tools.

There are obviously countless more proactive risk controls, but the primary way to identify a proactive risk control is to determine whether or not the risk control is used to detect or avoid undesirable safety events. If so, then the risk control should be considered a proactive risk control.

Monitoring and implementing proactive risk controls are critically-essential activities for all proactive risk management practitioners. This is one of the core activities of the SMS. In fact, when the FAA was drafting SMS legislation, they stated the purpose of SMS implementations as:

The objective of Safety Management Systems (SMS) is to proactively manage safety, to identify potential hazards, to determine risk, and to implement measures that mitigate the risk. The FAA envisions operators being able to use all of the components of SMS to enhance a carrier’s ability to identify safety issues and spot trends before they result in a near-miss, incident, or accident. For this reason, the FAA is requiring carriers to develop and implement an SMS. Federal Register / Vol 80, No.5 (emphasis added).

Being able to implement risk controls that are proactive requires a detailed understanding of:

  • The affected system(s);
  • Hazards inherent within the affected systems;
  • Credible, potential hazard-related consequences;
  • Dynamics and root causes of hazard risks;
  • Why hazards consequences may increase in severity in risk-situations; and
  • How to properly detect manifesting hazards, avoid threats and/or negate the severity of them.

Related Articles on Monitoring Risk Controls in Aviation SMS

What Are Primary Goals of Proactive Risk Controls?

The primary goals of proactive risk controls center around pre-risk operations. Once a hazard has manifested itself, different types of controls are used to address potential hazard-related consequences.

Whereas mitigative controls often exist in the realm of being able to make decisions, proactive controls usually exist on a level of safety awareness. What this means is that proactive controls:

  • Help employees be aware of safe conduct (procedures, wayfinding-signs, runway lights, etc.)
  • Help people identify objects, behaviors, and situations that are threatening; and
  • Aid people in the ability to efficiently ameliorate hazards before they cause a risk-event.

We measure the effectiveness of proactive controls in two ways:

  1. Qualitatively: how well does the risk control clarify how to continue safe operations?
  2. Quantitatively: how often is this control associated with a risk-event (i.e., how often does the risk control fail to fulfill its safety-purpose)? 

Download Risk Management Procedural Workflows

What Is a Mitigative Risk Control

Mitigative risk controls in aviation SMS-programs

Mitigative risk controls in aviation SMS are implemented with the purpose of:

  • Deescalating a safety situation after suffering from hazard related consequences;
  • Returning operations to safety;
  • Avoiding additional, potential damages and impacts; and
  • Lessening unavoidable damages.

Some example of mitigative risk controls are:

  • Evasive maneuvers;
  • Neurology of decision making training;
  • Design standards of aircraft (such as being able to withstand damages);
  • Post-risk procedures; and
  • Runway monitoring technology.

There are as many mitigative as proactive risk controls, but the hallmark of any mitigative risk control is that it is put in place in order to help return to safe operations once safe operations are lost.

It would be easy to say that mitigative risk controls are not as “ideal” as proactive risk controls because mitigative controls arise from reactive risk management. However, this is a terrible misconception that that exists in some safety cultures. Mitigative risk controls are as critical (if not more) to safe operations as proactive risk controls.

Being able to implement risk controls that are mitigative requires a details understanding of:

  • Historical safety performance;
  • The probable hazard-related consequences of risk-events that go unchecked; and
  • Best ways to respond to risk-events in order to eliminate/reduce damages.

Related Aviation Risk Management Articles

What Are the Goals of Mitigative Risk Controls?

The primary goals of risk controls that mitigate are:

  1. Enhance decision making ability of employees;
  2. Help operations return to a point of safety; and
  3. Eliminate or reduce the severity of consequences.

Some risks can be eliminated completely with proper actions. Other risk, such as low-probability, high-impact risks, can be very difficult to avoid and so require actions that attempt to lessen inevitable damages.

Mitigative risk controls absolutely require risk analysis and recurrent risk assessments on the risk. Uncertainties around severity and likelihood of various damages will make a risk-event all but impossible to eliminate or mitigate once it has occurred.

Mitigative risk controls correspond to aviation lagging indicators, because they rely on historical performance. In other words, in actual operational environments mitigative risk controls are almost always implemented in response to some kind of safety event.

Hazard and Risk Knowledge Quiz

Final Thoughts on Risk Controls in Aviation SMS

Risk controls have always been a "big deal" in aviation SMS; however, there has not been sufficient guidance on how to monitor risk controls. Furthermore, regulatory authorities have not been focusing too heavily on risk controls during their regular SMS audits. This will change.

An SMS implementation may require three to five years to fully implement. During the first years, SMS auditors are focused on the structure of a compliant SMS. Does the operator have all the "pieces" required for a compliant SMS implementation?

Once the SMS implementation is expected to be "mature," SMS auditors become more demanding. They are wanting to see a demonstration of the SMS' performance and how risk controls are evaluated for effectiveness. In order to demonstrate whether a risk control is effective, you will need to analyze and measure their effectiveness on a regular basis. Evaluating risk controls in a spreadsheet is a non-starter, as the process is not efficient, nor is it sustainable for prolonged time periods.

Do you have a way to analyze control measures in your risk management process? If your SMS is in phase 3 or phase 4, then you should have a way to document risk controls. For an auditor, if there is no documentation, then it didn't happen. A best practice is to document risk controls in a centralized database and then review them whenever a new safety issue enters your risk management process.

If you don't have the tools to monitor and measure your risk controls, we can help.


Are you monitoring your risk controls? Can you select a risk control from your list of control measures and tell me how many times it has failed within the past year, two years or five years?

If you are interested in improving your risk management activities, check out these short demo videos to learn how we can help. Since 2007, SMS Pro has been providing SMS data management tools to the aviation industry to specifically address the ICAO SMS mandate. SMS Pro is considered as the best SMS database on the market. SMS Pro is not cheap, but it provides tremendous value to your SMS.

Watch SMS Pro Demo Videos

 

Published January 2017. Last updated April 2019.

Topics: 2-Safety Risk Management

Site content provided by Northwest Data Solutions is meant for informational purposes only. Opinions presented here are not provided by any civil aviation authority or standards body.

 

 

Benefits of SMS Pro Database

Request live demo to learn about aviation safety management system database software

Best Practices for Aviation SMS

 

Watch SMS Pro Demo Videos

These two on-demand videos offer:

  • High-level overview of SMS Pro;
  • Hazard Reporting & Risk Management walk-through.
Watch SMS Pro Demo Videos
 
 
 
 

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts